Assessment Tools
•
Understanding the purpose of reference calls
Why reference calls matter in the hiring process
Reference calls are a crucial step in the hiring process, providing hiring managers with a clearer picture of a job candidate beyond what is seen in the interview or on social media. While resumes and interviews offer valuable insights, they may not always reveal how a person truly performs in a work environment or fits into a team. Conducting reference checks helps validate the information provided by candidates and uncovers details that can influence the hiring decision.
When you check references, you are not just confirming employment dates or job titles. You are also gathering context about the candidate’s work style, strengths, and areas for improvement. This process can help identify potential red flags or positive signals that may not have surfaced during the interview. Asking the right questions during a reference call gives you a more complete understanding of whether the candidate is the best fit for the role and your organization.
- Reference checks help verify the accuracy of a candidate’s claims about their previous roles and responsibilities.
- They provide real-world examples of how the candidate handles challenges, works with others, and adapts to change.
- Reference calls can reveal patterns in a candidate’s behavior that may impact their success in the new job.
It’s important to approach reference calls with clear objectives and a respectful attitude. The questions you ask should be designed to help you make a fair and informed hiring decision, while also respecting the privacy of both the candidate and their references. For a deeper understanding of how reference checks fit into the overall hiring process, you can read more about the role of staff appraisals in hiring.
Preparing for the reference call
Setting the Stage for an Effective Reference Call
Before you pick up the phone to conduct reference checks, preparation is key. The hiring process is already complex, and reference calls can provide valuable insights about a candidate’s fit for the job. But to get the most out of these conversations, hiring managers need to be organized and intentional.- Review the candidate’s application and interview notes: Take time to understand the candidate’s work history, employment dates, and the specific role they are being considered for. This helps tailor your questions to the candidate job context.
- Clarify your goals for the reference check: Are you verifying skills, checking for red flags, or seeking examples of how the person handles challenges? Knowing your objectives will help you focus your questions and time.
- Prepare a list of core questions: Having a set of questions ready ensures you cover all important areas, from job performance to cultural fit. This also helps maintain consistency when checking references for multiple candidates.
- Confirm consent and gather accurate contact information: Make sure the candidate has given permission to contact their references. Double-check the reference’s role and relationship to the candidate to avoid surprises during the call.
- Schedule the call thoughtfully: Give references enough notice and choose a time that works for both parties. This shows respect and increases the chance of a candid conversation.
Core questions to ask when calling for a reference
Key questions to guide your reference check
When you conduct reference calls, it’s important to ask questions that reveal the candidate’s true work style, strengths, and potential red flags. The right questions help hiring managers get a clearer picture of how the candidate performed in previous roles and how they might fit into your team. Here are some essential questions to consider during your reference check:
- Can you confirm the candidate’s employment dates and job title? This helps verify the accuracy of the candidate’s resume and ensures you’re speaking with someone who worked closely with them.
- What was your relationship to the candidate? Understanding the reference’s position and connection to the candidate provides context for their feedback.
- What were the candidate’s main responsibilities in their role? This question clarifies the scope of the candidate’s work and whether it aligns with your job requirements.
- How would you describe the candidate’s work ethic and reliability? Insights here can help you assess if the candidate will meet your expectations for commitment and professionalism.
- Can you share an example of how the candidate handled a challenging situation? This question gives you a sense of the candidate’s problem-solving skills and resilience.
- How did the candidate interact with colleagues and supervisors? Understanding how the candidate works with people is crucial for team dynamics.
- Would you rehire this person? Why or why not? This is a direct way to gauge the reference’s overall impression and identify any potential red flags.
These questions reference both the candidate’s technical abilities and interpersonal skills, which are equally important in the hiring process. Tailoring your reference check questions to the specific job and industry can help you get the most relevant insights. For example, if you’re hiring for a manufacturing role, you might want to optimize your assessment strategies to focus on safety and process adherence.
Remember, reference checks are not just about confirming facts—they’re about understanding the candidate’s potential fit for your organization. Asking the right questions when checking references will help you make a more informed hiring decision and avoid surprises down the line.
Digging deeper: behavioral and situational questions
Going Beyond the Basics: Behavioral and Situational Insights
Once you’ve covered the essentials like employment dates and job responsibilities, it’s time to dig deeper. Behavioral and situational questions during a reference call can reveal how a candidate actually performed in real work situations. These questions help hiring managers understand not just what the candidate did, but how and why they did it. This approach can be especially useful when checking references for roles that require adaptability, teamwork, or problem-solving.
- Can you describe a time when the candidate faced a significant challenge at work? How did they handle it? This question helps you assess resilience and problem-solving skills.
- How did the candidate respond to feedback or criticism? Understanding their openness to growth is key for many roles.
- Can you share an example of when the candidate worked as part of a team? What role did they play? This gives insight into collaboration and communication abilities.
- Tell me about a situation where the candidate had to adapt to a major change. How did they manage? Adaptability is increasingly important in today’s fast-changing work environments.
- Was there a time when the candidate went above and beyond their job requirements? This can help you spot high performers.
These questions reference real scenarios, encouraging the person providing the reference to share specific stories rather than general impressions. It’s important to listen for details that match what the candidate shared during their interview. Consistency between the candidate’s account and the reference’s perspective can strengthen your confidence in your hiring decision.
When conducting reference checks, remember that not every reference will have witnessed every type of situation. If a reference can’t answer a question, that’s not necessarily a red flag, but it’s worth noting how they respond. The best reference calls are those where you get a clear, honest picture of the candidate’s behavior and potential fit for the job.
Red flags and positive signals to listen for
Signals to Watch for During Reference Checks
When conducting a reference call, it’s important to listen for both positive signals and potential red flags. These cues can help hiring managers make a more informed hiring decision about a candidate. Here’s what to keep in mind:- Inconsistencies in employment dates or job roles: If the reference’s account of the candidate’s work history doesn’t match the resume or interview, this could indicate a problem. Always clarify any discrepancies with follow-up questions.
- Reluctance or vagueness: When references are hesitant to answer questions or provide only generic responses, it may suggest they have reservations about the candidate’s performance or behavior.
- Overly positive or scripted answers: While positive feedback is good, responses that sound rehearsed or lack specific examples may not provide an accurate picture of the candidate’s abilities.
- Negative comments about teamwork or attitude: Pay attention if a reference mentions issues with collaboration, reliability, or adaptability. These traits are often crucial for success in most roles.
- Unwillingness to rehire: One of the most telling reference check questions is whether the reference would hire the candidate again. A hesitant or negative answer is a clear red flag.
- Missing details about achievements: If references struggle to recall specific accomplishments or contributions, it may indicate the candidate did not stand out in their previous job.
Positive Indicators to Note
On the other hand, some signals can help confirm a candidate is the right fit:- Enthusiastic endorsements: References who are genuinely enthusiastic and provide detailed examples of the candidate’s strengths and impact are a strong sign.
- Consistency with interview feedback: When the reference’s answers align with what the candidate shared during the interview, it builds trust in the hiring process.
- Clear examples of problem-solving and adaptability: References who can describe how the candidate handled challenges or adapted to change show the candidate’s potential value to your team.
- Positive comments about growth and learning: If references mention the candidate’s willingness to learn and improve, it’s a good indicator for long-term success in a new role.
Respecting privacy and legal considerations
Balancing Insight with Confidentiality
When conducting reference checks, it’s essential to respect both the candidate’s privacy and legal boundaries. While you want to gather meaningful information to help with your hiring decision, there are clear lines you should not cross.- Stick to job-related questions: Focus your questions on the candidate’s work performance, employment dates, and suitability for the role. Avoid personal topics such as health, family, or beliefs, which are not relevant and could be legally sensitive.
- Be aware of local laws: Different regions have specific regulations about what you can ask during a reference call. For example, some places restrict questions about salary history or reasons for leaving a previous job. Make sure you’re up to date on these requirements to avoid legal risks.
- Handle sensitive information carefully: If a reference shares concerns or red flags about a candidate, treat this information with discretion. Don’t share it widely or use it in a way that could be considered discriminatory.
- Get consent from the candidate: Always ensure the candidate has given permission for you to contact their references. This is not only respectful but often required by company policy or law.
- Document your process: Keep a record of the questions you ask and the responses you receive. This helps show that your hiring process is fair and consistent for all candidates.
